Beyond LCOE: A multi-criteria evaluation framework for offshore renewable energy projects

URI

https://tethys-engineering.pnnl.gov/node/20032

description

The transition to low-carbon energy systems is a complex process that implies radical technological changes, greenhouse gas emission reductions, and benefits to the local economies yet, also significant investment, a need for capacity building, strengthening supply chains and supporting legal frameworks. Consequently, the choice ofrenewable energy technologiesshould be based on a comprehensive assessment addressing the different dimensions that are affected.Clean energy technologiesare traditionally evaluated on the basis of their techno-economic performance. Such an approach penalises emerging energy technologies that are generally more capital-intensive given their innovation requirement and the lack of support mechanisms facilitating their industrial roll-out. In this paper, a multi-criteria evaluation framework is proposed encompassing three important broad dimensions: techno-economics, environment and socio-economics. The applicability and flexibility of the proposed evaluation framework are demonstrated on different case studies. First, the hypothetical deployment of a floatingoffshore wind farmboth in Scotland and Portugal is evaluated. Later, the proposed framework is used to evaluate the deployments of wave energy devices in the same two locations. The results show that this multi-criteria approach provides a more holistic overview of the performance and implications of renewable energy technologies, particularly emerging ones, and can better support decision- and policy-making in the medium- and long-term. Furthermore, the framework can be used by researchers, investors, developers and/or analysts to assess energy planning alternatives.

originationDate

spatial

POINT (-1.593169495974 57.559437613425)

author

Vanegas-Cantarero, M.
Pennock, S.
Bloise-Thomaz, T.
Jeffrey, H.
Dickson, M.

organization

University of Edinburgh
CorPower Ocean

tags

Engineering
Cost Assessment
Levelized Cost of Energy
Site Characterization
Modeling

source

tethys-engineering.pnnl.gov

technology

Current
Tidal
Wave
Point Absorber

PRIMRE Type Ref