As part of its mission to support the global deployment of wind energy through a better understanding of environmental issues, WREN has created a free, online tool to catalog monitoring and mitigating technologies developed to assess and reduce potential wildlife impacts resulting from land-based and offshore wind energy development. The tool will be continuously maintained and updated to ensure the international community has access to current, publicly available information on monitoring and mitigation solutions, their state of development, and related research on their effectiveness.
Results can be refined by selecting from the drop down menus or entering a search term. Listed monitoring and mitigation technologies are reviewed on an annual basis, but can be updated more frequently if needed, by emailing tethys@pnnl.gov. The wind energy community may also contribute additional technologies for consideration by filling out this survey.
You can also download the full list of monitoring and mitigation technologies or look up definition of terms used in this tool.
Type | Stressor & Receptor | Technology | Description | Placement & Integration | Research Summary | Citations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MonitoringOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Marine Mammals | HiDef SPACEWHALE | SPACEWHALE detects whales from VHR satellite imagery by merging deep learning assets with the knowledge of biologists....Read more SPACEWHALE detects whales from VHR satellite imagery by merging deep learning assets with the knowledge of biologists. The technology offers abundance estimates for large whales on a per-survey basis, distribution maps of target species in ESRI-compatible raster formats, and bespoke analyses to help guide conservation and advanced ecological studies. Read less |
Software operated on a computer |
Pilot Field Study
Höschle et al. (2022) developed a method that uses a Faster-RCNN object detection algorithm to process VHR imagery, and this has been packaged as the SPACEWHALE service....Read more Höschle et al. (2022) developed a method that uses a Faster-RCNN object detection algorithm to process VHR imagery, and this has been packaged as the SPACEWHALE service. The service was tested with WorldView-2 archival images (~0.50m resolution) of Port Ross, Auckland Island - Maukahuka in August 2020, providing additional coverage and possible whale detections in a secondary area that has received little on-the-water survey effort. Borowicz et al. (2019) proposed a semi-automated pipeline for whale detection from very high-resolution (VHR; sub-meter) satellite imagery with the use of Convolutional Neural Network. ResNet and DenseNet CNNs were trained, and tested each model on 31cm-resolution imagery obtained from the WorldView-3 sensor, achieving classification accuracy of 100% tiles with whales, and 94% of tiles containing only water. Read less |
Höschle et al. 2021, Borowicz et al. 2019 |
Monitoring, MitigationLand-based, OffshoreOperation, Planning, Construction | Turbine Collision, Habitat Alteration, DisplacementBirds | Spoor Spoor AI Bird Monitoring System | Spoor´s software aims to use computer vision and AI to detect, track, and classify birds in wind farms to help developers and operators gain insights and guide mitigation measures....Read more Spoor´s software aims to use computer vision and AI to detect, track, and classify birds in wind farms to help developers and operators gain insights and guide mitigation measures. Spoor is intended to help developers to improve understanding of how birds behave while travelling in the vicinity of wind farms. Read less |
Mounted on the turbine service platform, floating buoys, and other wind farm infrastructure |
Large-Scale Field Study
The Spoor AI system is currently installed at the Unitech Zefyros floating turbine test site off the coast of Norway and in the North Sea. Additionally, it has been installed at four Land-based sites and will be installed on Equinor's Hywind Tampen Windfarm. Results are currently unpublished. |
Nicholls et al. 2022 |
MonitoringOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Habitat AlterationFish, Invertebrates, Marine Mammals | Saildrone Surveyor | The Saildrone Surveyor is a 72-foot USV providing IHO-compliant multibeam ocean mapping that exceeds the quality delivered by traditional methods. The Surveyor can map continuously for over 180 days and delivering hydrographic information. |
Free moving solar, wind and diesel powered USV |
Large-Scale Field Study
In 2022, Saildrone received funding to combine its technologies with artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies to create a line-of-sight monitoring network to detect, classify, and localize marine mammals in areas with offshore wind developments on the U.S. Atlantic Coast. |
No available documents. |
Monitoring, MitigationLand-based, OffshoreOperation | Avoidance, Turbine Collision, AttractionBirds | Volacam The Bird Collision Avoidance System (BCAS Wind) | The BCAS Wind is a fully automated detection and deterrence solution for on- and off-shore wind turbines. With long range detection and deterrence capabilities, the system minimizes WTG stoppages providing fewer interruptions to operation and power generation....Read more The BCAS Wind is a fully automated detection and deterrence solution for on- and off-shore wind turbines. With long range detection and deterrence capabilities, the system minimizes WTG stoppages providing fewer interruptions to operation and power generation. The system operates 24/7 without any operator input and functions in all weather conditions. The system uses a variety of sensors including a thermal imaging camera and an acoustic module. Read less |
Two units on turbine tower |
Large-Scale Field Study
Georgiev et al. (2022) analyzed the detection rate efficiency of the BCAS wind system at a wind farm in the Kaliakra region in NE Bulgaria from August to October 2020. |
Georgiev and Zehtindjiev 2022 |
MonitoringOffshore, Land-basedOperation | Turbine CollisionBats | Wageningen University Thermal Stereo Vision Application | The Thermal Stereo Vision Application aims to better understand bat movements in the area surrounding an offshore wind turbine through the collection of 3D and 2D flight path data. The system consists of two thermal cameras in a stereoscopic setup in addition to ultrasonic microphones. |
Two synchronized thermal cameras in the vicinity of the turbine, three ultrasound microphones mounted on the turbine tower at varying heights |
Small-Scale Field Study
Lagerveld et al. (2020) evaluated various technologies developed to detect bird and bat collisions with wind turbines. ...Read more Lagerveld et al. (2020) evaluated various technologies developed to detect bird and bat collisions with wind turbines.
Lagerveld et al. (2017) conducted a feasibility study evaluating the use of thermal cameras in a stereoscopic setup to record bat flight paths at an offshore wind turbine. The study was conducted between August and September 2016 at an offshore wind operation in Wieringermeer, the Netherlands. Read less |
Lagerveld et al. 2020, Lagerveld et al. 2017 |
MonitoringLand-based, OffshorePlanning, Operation | Attraction, Avoidance, Turbine CollisionBirds, Bats | PNNL ThermalTracker-3D | The ThermalTracker-3D system records the flight tracks of birds and bats around offshore wind turbines. A pair of thermal video cameras sense movement of animals and objects, day and night, and stereo-vision processing transforms the recorded motion tracks into three dimensions....Read more The ThermalTracker-3D system records the flight tracks of birds and bats around offshore wind turbines. A pair of thermal video cameras sense movement of animals and objects, day and night, and stereo-vision processing transforms the recorded motion tracks into three dimensions. Real-time processing reduces data storage and bandwidth requirements. For floating applications, the ThermalTracker-3D may require camera stabilization to compensate for wave motion. Read less |
Located on ground, surface, or floating platform, looking upward at turbine blades |
Pilot Field Study
Matzner et al. (2022) describe the integration of the ThermalTracker-3D system with a wind-profiling buoy and deployment offshore in California. The system was deployed for 14 weeks between May and August 2021, collecting seabird activity data, including nocturnal activity. ...Read more Matzner et al. (2022) describe the integration of the ThermalTracker-3D system with a wind-profiling buoy and deployment offshore in California. The system was deployed for 14 weeks between May and August 2021, collecting seabird activity data, including nocturnal activity.
Matzner et al. (2020) present a method for tracking the flight trajectories of birds and bats and creating composite images of flight trajectories with data from thermal cameras. Drones were used to assess accuracy of detections near a wind farm in Boulder, Colorado (US) during 2020. Read less |
Matzner et al. 2022, Matzner et al. 2020, Matzner et al. 2015 |
MonitoringOffshore, Land-basedOperation, Planning | Turbine Collision, DisplacementBirds, Bats | Dr. Aaron Corcoran (UC Colorado Springs) and Dr. Tyson Hedrick (Univ. North Carolina) ThruTracker | ThruTracker is a software platform developed for video-based automated animal tracking. The software aims to use time synchronized video from two or more cameras to detect moving objects (such as birds, bats, or insects) within a stationary background....Read more ThruTracker is a software platform developed for video-based automated animal tracking. The software aims to use time synchronized video from two or more cameras to detect moving objects (such as birds, bats, or insects) within a stationary background. The system can be used for 2 dimensional analysis with a single video feed. Read less |
Software platform, requires time-synchronized video feeds |
Small-Scale Field Study
Jaffe et al. (2022) compared methods of conducting population surveys by using traditional techniques (visual counting) and novel ones (passive acoustic detection, drone-acquired thermal imagery). ThruTracker software was used to partially automate the visual counting method. ...Read more Jaffe et al. (2022) compared methods of conducting population surveys by using traditional techniques (visual counting) and novel ones (passive acoustic detection, drone-acquired thermal imagery). ThruTracker software was used to partially automate the visual counting method.
Corcoran et al. (2021) discussed ThruTracker algorithms, development, and testing. Two case studies using ThruTracker software are presented. One study involved counting bats in North Carolina (US) in August of 2020 with the software using thermal imaging as a video feed. The other case study evaluated the spatial accuracy obtained from using a wind turbine as a calibration object. Read less |
Jaffe et al. 2022, Corcoran et al. 2021 |
Monitoring, MitigationLand-based, OffshoreOperation | Turbine CollisionBats | TopWind TopWind Bat Protection System (BPS) | An ultrasound microphone is installed in the nacelle base near the rotor, and at tip-low for larger turbines. The Bat Protection System has a detection range of 45 meters, and can inform automated start/stop functions as informed curtailment or activity-based informed curtailment. |
One microphone in the nacelle and an additional microphone at tip-low for towers over 120 meters |
No available documents. | |
MonitoringOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Habitat AlterationMarine Mammals, Habitat, Fish | OceanAero TRITON | The TRITON is an Autonomous Underwater and Surface Vehicle (AUSV). It can sail and submerge autonomously to collect data both above and below the ocean’s surface. Powered by the sun and wind, the TRITON can be used for extended deployments....Read more The TRITON is an Autonomous Underwater and Surface Vehicle (AUSV). It can sail and submerge autonomously to collect data both above and below the ocean’s surface. Powered by the sun and wind, the TRITON can be used for extended deployments. The optional payloads include advanced modal communications for high bandwidth data transfer in remote areas as well as obstacle avoidance software/hardware to ensure autonomous reactions to unexpected mission complications. The TRITON provides live water chemistry reads, animal tracking, habitat monitoring, weather observation, seabed mapping, and more. Read less |
Deployed in water around wind farm |
No available documents. | |
Monitoring, MitigationLand-basedOperation | Turbine CollisionBats | EPRI, Normandeau Associates Inc Turbine Integrated Mortality Reduction (TIMR) | Turbine Integrated Mortality Reduction (TIMR) is a detection-based curtailment system which aims to reduce bat-turbine collisions and economic losses to curtailment....Read more Turbine Integrated Mortality Reduction (TIMR) is a detection-based curtailment system which aims to reduce bat-turbine collisions and economic losses to curtailment. The TIMR system is composed of sound detection hardware (ReBAT®) and software (TIMR server) which uses acoustic and meteorological data to calculate the risk of bat collisions. The TIMR smart curtailment system is an alternative to blanket curtailment as it only curtails when bat echolocation calls are detected. Read less |
Two acoustic microphones mounted on the nacelle and a server at the plant operating center |
Large-Scale Field Study
EPRI (2021) modeled wind variables, curtailment thresholds, and bat activity patterns to analyze the possible influences of various curtailment strategies on wind energy production at six wind energy facilities in Alberta, Canada. ...Read more EPRI (2021) modeled wind variables, curtailment thresholds, and bat activity patterns to analyze the possible influences of various curtailment strategies on wind energy production at six wind energy facilities in Alberta, Canada.
Hayes et al. (2019) compared the reduction in bat fatalities associated with the implementation of the TIMR system at a wind energy facility in Wisconsin (US) in 2015 to the reduction measured using blanket curtailment strategies at other sites in North America and Europe. Read less |
Newman 2021, Hayes et al. 2019 |
MitigationLand-based, OffshoreOperation | Turbine CollisionBats | Iowa State University Ultrasonic Blade-mounted Deterrent | The Ultrasonic Blade-mounted Deterrent is an adaptation of the dog whistle which generates high-intensity ultrasonic sound with the aim of deterring bats from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine....Read more The Ultrasonic Blade-mounted Deterrent is an adaptation of the dog whistle which generates high-intensity ultrasonic sound with the aim of deterring bats from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine. The deterrent operates passively using air traveling over the turbine blades on which it is mounted. Read less |
Deterrent mounted on blades |
Laboratory
Sharma (2021) tested the ultrasonic whistle concept at varying air pressures and whistle frequencies at Iowa State University (US).
Zeng et al. (2021) analysed the mechanisms and frequency of an ultrasound whistle at three pressure regimes. |
Sharma 2021, Zeng and Sharma 2021 |
MitigationLand-basedOperation | Turbine CollisionBats | General Electric Ultrasonic Nacelle-mounted Deterrent | The GE ultrasonic deterrent system aims to reduce the number of bats from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine by producing broad-band sound in a frequency audible to most bat species (30-100 kHz)....Read more The GE ultrasonic deterrent system aims to reduce the number of bats from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine by producing broad-band sound in a frequency audible to most bat species (30-100 kHz). Compressed air moving through ultrasonic nozzles positioned on the tower of a wind turbine generates the ultrasonic deterrent sound. Read less |
Ultrasonic jets are mounted to the wind turbine tower with air compressors located inside the tower on the service platforms. |
Small-Scale Field Study
Romano et al. (2019) conducted a randomized block experiment at a wind farm in Illinois (US) during the autumn bat migration between 2014 and 2016 to evaluate the efficacy of the GE Ultrasonic bat deterrence system in preventing bat fatalities due to turbine collisions. ...Read more Romano et al. (2019) conducted a randomized block experiment at a wind farm in Illinois (US) during the autumn bat migration between 2014 and 2016 to evaluate the efficacy of the GE Ultrasonic bat deterrence system in preventing bat fatalities due to turbine collisions.
Kinzie et al. (2018) aimed to increase the efficacy of the GE 4-nozzle continuous ultrasonic system by 50%. The redesigned deterrent system includes a 6 nozzle system with a pulsing signal. Alterations were evaluated using acoustic and video recordings and 3D bat path visualization at wind farms in Texas and Illinois (US) from August to September of 2015. Read less |
Romano et al. 2019, Kinzie 2018 |
Monitoring, MitigationOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Turbine Collision, DisplacementBats, Birds | DeTect VESPER Fixed-Beam Vertical Profile Radar | VESPER Fixed-Beam Vertical Profile Radar works to provide species differentiation and identification of birds, insects, and bats based on measurement of wingbeat frequency as they pass through the beam....Read more VESPER Fixed-Beam Vertical Profile Radar works to provide species differentiation and identification of birds, insects, and bats based on measurement of wingbeat frequency as they pass through the beam. The VESPER system is capable of being operated independently or in concert with a MERLIN bird radar system to provide specific data on the type of target that has been detected, (i.e. bird, bat or insect) and allows inclusion/measurement of insect data.
DeTect has discontinued this product but uses aspects of the technology in the current MERLIN Radar. Read less |
Radar system located in the vicinity of the turbine |
Small-Scale Field Study
Tetra Tech Inc. (2012) used Vesper Radar as part of the pre construction monitoring of birds and bat at Block Island offshore wind farm.
Kelly et al. (2019) discusses the developement of Vesper Radar and the challenges of radar monitoring at offshore wind energy facilities. |
Tetra Tech Inc. 2012, Kelly et al. 2009 |
MonitoringOffshoreOperation, Planning | Turbine CollisionBirds | Institut für Angewandte Ökologie (IfAÖ) Visual Automatic Recording System (VARS) | The Visual Automatic Recording System (VARS) is a camera-based system developed for the detection of flying birds in the rotor-swept zone of offshore wind turbines....Read more The Visual Automatic Recording System (VARS) is a camera-based system developed for the detection of flying birds in the rotor-swept zone of offshore wind turbines. The system consists of two motion-controlled infrared cameras which intend to automatically record flying birds and a software system to detect birds and process imagery. Read less |
VARS cameras mounted on the nacelle and tower |
Small-Scale Field Study
Hill et al. (2014) deployed VARS in the German Alpha Ventus offshore wind farm between 2010 and 2013. Variations in the distribution of flying birds were observed to determine a potential collision rate per turbine. |
Hill et al. 2014 |
MonitoringOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Noise, Turbine CollisionMarine Mammals, Birds, Bats | Saildrone Voyager | The Saildrone Voyager, currently in development, is a 33-foot USV equipped with a set of metocean sensors and a continuous wave LiDAR....Read more The Saildrone Voyager, currently in development, is a 33-foot USV equipped with a set of metocean sensors and a continuous wave LiDAR. Saildrone’s passive acoustics, optical cameras, and advanced machine learning algorithms deliver real-time detection of anything in the vicinity of offshore wind farms—including commercial and recreational boats or other vessels that may choose not to transmit their position, as well identifying natural visitors like whales, seabirds, and bats to support environmental impact mitigation strategies. Read less |
Free moving solar, wind, and diesel powered USV |
Large-Scale Field Study
In 2022, Saildrone received funding to combine its technologies with artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies to create a line-of-sight monitoring network to detect, classify, and localize marine mammals in areas with offshore wind developments on the U.S. Atlantic Coast. |
No available documents. |
MonitoringOffshorePlanning, Construction, Operation, Decommissioning | Fish, Marine Mammals, Habitat | Liquid Robotics Wave Glider | The Liquid Robotics SV3-v300 Wave Glider is long-duration, zero-carbon (wave and solar powered), industry-proven marine surface platform....Read more The Liquid Robotics SV3-v300 Wave Glider is long-duration, zero-carbon (wave and solar powered), industry-proven marine surface platform. It is used for many kinds of monitoring – acoustics (passive and active), surface data, water column data, surface conditions (full METOC – meteorological and oceanic), video/photo data, infrared, etc. Read less |
Deployed in water |
Large-Scale Field Study
Tian et al....Read more Tian et al. (2023) explored the research progress of gliding robots applied in ocean observation, and discussed the wave glider's usage with carrying different sensors in various fields, including ocean biological monitoring, water measurement, marine ecological environment research, and marine meteorology. Cheong et al. (2021) demonstrated that the wave glider can be used in seismic surveys to obtain information required for offshore structure development. Read less |
Tian et al. 2022, Cheong et al. 2021 |
MonitoringLand-basedOperation, Planning | Turbine CollisionBats | Wildlife Imaging Systems LLC Wildlife Activity and Mortality Detection System | Wildlife Imaging Systems aims to improve wildlife monitoring and mortality assessments around operational wind turbines with automated artificial intelligence software paired with commercially available camera systems....Read more Wildlife Imaging Systems aims to improve wildlife monitoring and mortality assessments around operational wind turbines with automated artificial intelligence software paired with commercially available camera systems. The concept is to use three thermal cameras to monitor the airspace around the wind turbine, two cameras dedicated to monitoring wildlife mortality that falls to the ground and one camera dedicated to quantifying the activity in the turbine rotor swept area. The system software was developed to count and track wildlife flight paths. Read less |
Cameras mounted at the bottom of the turbine tower, accompanying artificial intelligence software |
No available documents. | |
MitigationOffshore, Land-basedOperation | Turbine CollisionBirds, Bats | Flash Technology Wind Turbine Obstruction Lighting | The Wind Turbine Obstruction Lighting system employs lights of FAA Type L-864 with the intent of deterring bats and birds from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine....Read more The Wind Turbine Obstruction Lighting system employs lights of FAA Type L-864 with the intent of deterring bats and birds from flying into the rotor swept zone of an operational wind turbine. Lights are pulsed at a rate of 30FPM and positioned so as to be visible from all directions as recommended by BOEM with the goal of reducing avian collision risk. Read less |
Per BOEM guidance: Two FAA Type L-864 mounted on opposite rear sides of the nacelle, three or more FAA Type L-810 spaced around mast |
Small-Scale Field Study
Kerlinger et al. (2010) analysed avian collision fatality data from 30 wind farms across the United States collected after 1995 to observe the effects of various types of obstruction lighting on avian mortalities. ...Read more Kerlinger et al. (2010) analysed avian collision fatality data from 30 wind farms across the United States collected after 1995 to observe the effects of various types of obstruction lighting on avian mortalities.
Gehring et al. (2009) studied the effects of various forms of obstruction lighting (flashing, non-flashing, white, red) on avian mortalities associated with communication towers in Michigan (US) from May to September of 2005.
Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (2021) guidelines for obstruction lighting implemented on offshore wind turbines. FAA Type L-864 pulsing lights at the highest point of the turbine nacelle are currently recommended for offshore wind turbines. Read less |
Kerlinger et al. 2010, Gehring et al. 2009, Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) 2021 |
MonitoringLand-based, OffshoreOperation | Turbine CollisionBirds, Bats | Oregon State University Wind Turbine Sensor Unit for Monitoring of Avian and Bat Collisions (WTSU) | The Wind Turbine Sensor Unit for Monitoring of Avian & Bat Collisions aims to detect the impact of an avian collision with the blades of an operational wind turbine. The sensor unit is triggered on impact and is composed of accelerometers, microphones (contact and bioacoustic)....Read more The Wind Turbine Sensor Unit for Monitoring of Avian & Bat Collisions aims to detect the impact of an avian collision with the blades of an operational wind turbine. The sensor unit is triggered on impact and is composed of accelerometers, microphones (contact and bioacoustic). Cameras (infrared and visual) installed on each blade will save a number of images before and after the event for impact confirmation and specie recognition. Read less |
Accelerometers and contact microphones installed at the base of each turbine blade, visual cameras mounted on tower, microphones mounted on the nacelle, and a computer system in the nacelle. |
Small-Scale Field Study
Albertani et al. (2021) discussed the development of the strike detection system. The visual deterrent was tested with wild eagles in Oregon (US) in January and February of 2020....Read more Albertani et al. (2021) discussed the development of the strike detection system. The visual deterrent was tested with wild eagles in Oregon (US) in January and February of 2020. The integrated system was evaluated at a turbine in Colorado (US) in October 2018 and July 2019, and in New Mexico in April 2019.
Hu et al. (2021) evaluated the sensitivity of the multi-sensor strike detection system at wind turbines in Tucumcari, New Mexico and Boulder, Colorado (US) using launched tennis balls.
Suryan et al. (2016) conducted individual component tests at laboratories and field sites in Corvallis and Newport, Oregon, and in Seattle and Sequim, Washington, as well as at the North American Wind Research and Training Center in New Mexico and the National Wind Technology Center in Colorado. A fully integrated system was tested at the National Wind Technology Center in October 2014 and April 2015. Read less |
Albertani et al. 2021, Hu et al. 2018, Suryan et al. 2016 |
MonitoringLand-based, OffshoreOperation | Turbine CollisionBirds | TNO (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research) WT-Bird | WT-Bird is a collision detection system which intends to detect and record avian collisions with wind turbine blades. The system uses sound processing software and microphones in the turbine blades with the intent of identifying collisions....Read more WT-Bird is a collision detection system which intends to detect and record avian collisions with wind turbine blades. The system uses sound processing software and microphones in the turbine blades with the intent of identifying collisions. Video recordings of identified collisions are stored for analysis. Read less |
Placed around the base of offshore wind infrastructure |
Small-Scale Field Study
Wiggelinkhuizen et al. (2006) tested the capacity of the WT-Bird system for detecting bird collisions with 50 gram bird dummies to simulate the bird species found in the coastal Netherlands. The authors also discuss the functionality of the prototype system. ...Read more Wiggelinkhuizen et al. (2006) tested the capacity of the WT-Bird system for detecting bird collisions with 50 gram bird dummies to simulate the bird species found in the coastal Netherlands. The authors also discuss the functionality of the prototype system.
Verhoef et al. (2004) discuss the development and testing of the WT-Bird system as well as the unresolved challenges at the end of the project. The WT-Bird system was tested with tennis balls at a 500KW turbine near Rotterdam, the Netherlands in 2004. Read less |
Wiggelinkhuizen et al. 2006, Verhoef et al. 2004 |